Malayalam Music Industry in Chaos?
Tuesday, April 25, 2006
Is the Malayalam music industry (including film & album) in chaos? Is it in utter mayhem? Are the signs ominous? Well going by the signs it sadly seems so. I am not in fact commenting specifically on the abilities of any of the technicians & artists here but it seems that their careers are fast on the verge of closure. This is evident by the fact that out of the many cassette companies like Sargam, East Coast, Johny Sagarika, Manorama Music, Satyam Audio etc…only few have managed to survive.Music outlets are fast vanishing. Only Satyam Audio is active in the market in the case of Film Music. Manorama also is only coming up with film music very rarely. East Coast is mostly into low budget items like Mappila Pattukal. The glorious days of Ninakkai, Aadyamai etc….are over for them. It’s also astonishing to see that even Satyam is coming up with Audio CD’s with songs of many films put together selling for a paltry amount of Rs. 50/- This shows the desperation prevailing all over. Audio piracy, MP3, Broadband Internet, all have contributed to this. With the advent of the mushrooming home recording studios which have bloomed all over Kerala like a cottage industry, many of the reputed Recording Studios are facing closure. They are not able to cope up to the pressure. With the plummeting prices of computers a stage has come where even novices could record their own songs at home with the minimum of recording gear! The bad effect of such home studios are evident from the utter nursery rhyme type of music which is coming up on T.V channels in the name of music Albums. These songs have crappy “painkili” lyrics (himanglish? Hindi+ Malayalam+English). There is no maturity in these creations and many of the so called “kutti music directors” do not even know their music properly. The videos are also of utter low standards (the typical girl-boy on a bike or on the beach or in the water in the sea… story). I doubt whether in recent times any musical video has had the standards of the “Ormakkai” song from the East Coast album that was done by the genius “Shyamaprasad”. It's sad that even though many singers including myself would like to sing good songs they are forced to do such numbers as majority of the songs produced are of such kind. There are exceptions also as in every field. But majority are crap as also evident in the form of single or two songs in recent action thriller films. Most of such songs are reportedly done a shoestring budget of Rs. 25,000 to 50,000 ! How could film music be produced in such a small budget? This of course is done with compromises. A keyboard with MIDI and a computer with sound samples (Thanks to Broadband and software piracy) along with a sound card and a decent microphone are the hardware you need to get you going. Since these so called music directors have to work under such shoestring budgets, they never use original acoustic instruments. So Tabla Players, Sitar Players, Drum Players, Violin players, all are facing serious threats to their careers. Singers are willing to “sponser” their songs. This trend has been there since 4 or 5 years and has given a beating to even many of the senior pros, who in their days of glory resorted to unholy means to prevent new talents from coming on to the field. Now they are reaping the rewards of their doings. For the senior pros music is a career and money from film singing is their bread and butter. But in the case of the new breed of singers most of them are from affluent families and singing in films only is to add to the glamour. So they started new ways of beating it to the pros. They started sponsoring their own songs! Great isn’t it? But it worked. Many of them got hit numbers thanks to the booming T.V channels. When you keep on playing a song for thousands of times, eventually it becomes a hit even if the singer sings like buffaloes, crows or frogs! And then the “malayali” would finally say…Buffaloes also have a manly voice! Now when did someone say that frogs also croaked in a feminine voice? That’s the trick of marketing! So finally as a result of all these, a juncture has come when you cannot survive by singing in films or bringing out albums. If you manage to have a hit, it will give you programs in and out of India and would add to your moolah. But compared to what their Tamil & Hindi counterparts earn elsewhere, Malayali Singers earn peanuts! The “malayali” listener has short memories. Even if you have a hit you have to take the same initial steps for the next song, and the next song, and the next song…….Even the Maestro Illayaraja astonishingly uses very few acoustic instruments now a days. If you listen to his latest songs in Achuvine Amma, Rasathantram etc. you will note that violin ensembles are things of the past. It’s a great loss to the genuine music lover. The plummeting sale of music CD’s and cassettes has reduced the budget that’s allocated for film music. Now nobody bothers who sings or who composes. This is because nobody sustains for long. So what is the answer to all this mayhem? Well, I will come up with some suggestions in my next blog.
[ back home ]
Comments for Malayalam Music Industry in Chaos?
I think the change of time has to be accepted. It is true that some of the "kutti musicians" you said are not any good, but I think that doesn't have anything to do with the homestudios or Internet revolution. Even if there isn't this revolution of homestudios or internet, it will still happen since the young generation these days need it so badly. But it is not to be blamed on them that they accept only the fast music. Youngsters in Kerala has a good ear for soft melodies also. And its a pre-conceieved notion that they only like fast music.
I think the CDs being sold for Rs. 50 also helps the companies to sell more CDs. In my case, I used to get a copy the CDs from friends. But since the price of CDs slashed down, I go buy it for 50 bucks from the music store. This can also help to reduce the audio piracy. Who will prefer to make a copy for 20 bucks when the master print is available for rs. 50?
And another thing - How many of the current day musicians are talented like Ravindran master, Johnson etc? People have no choice when they are fed with the crap.
What you said about using the accoustic instruments is a very sad thing. But I don't understand why they can't bear those charges since the recording technologies have changed and the studio rentals are cheap these days.
The Internet revolution has a good side of it. In the mainstream music industry, people need to have a godfather or strong connections or lobbying to get the right recognition. And for the people who couldn't get into the music career due to their other commitments in life its a dream which they never going to accomplish. But the times have changed. The revolution of broadband internet connection, audioblogging etc are here for good. Now anybody who has a good voice or good composing abilities can present himself/herself to the world and get the proper recognition.
I think the CDs being sold for Rs. 50 also helps the companies to sell more CDs. In my case, I used to get a copy the CDs from friends. But since the price of CDs slashed down, I go buy it for 50 bucks from the music store. This can also help to reduce the audio piracy. Who will prefer to make a copy for 20 bucks when the master print is available for rs. 50?
And another thing - How many of the current day musicians are talented like Ravindran master, Johnson etc? People have no choice when they are fed with the crap.
What you said about using the accoustic instruments is a very sad thing. But I don't understand why they can't bear those charges since the recording technologies have changed and the studio rentals are cheap these days.
The Internet revolution has a good side of it. In the mainstream music industry, people need to have a godfather or strong connections or lobbying to get the right recognition. And for the people who couldn't get into the music career due to their other commitments in life its a dream which they never going to accomplish. But the times have changed. The revolution of broadband internet connection, audioblogging etc are here for good. Now anybody who has a good voice or good composing abilities can present himself/herself to the world and get the proper recognition.
hi pradip, aren't you taking this to the superficial hights and being irrational!!there are stuggling singers , who make it to the top some day, but thats how the pseudo systam works, one man army seldom succeed. any how keep up the good work.
sapna george ( freelance journalist)
sapna george ( freelance journalist)
- Posted at 1:49 PM | By സ്വപ്നം swapnam
Its great to get first hand information from the music industry, thanks Mr. Pradip.
Since I do not sing and am only a listener, may be I can present a consumer's view on this grave issue.
1. There are three ways for a song to reach me- when I hear it while watching the movie, when I watch song scenes on TV or hearing it at a public place & finding it appealing to me.
Now, there has to be a real appealing movie to get me spending a few hundred rupees and keep shut inside foul air chambers called cinema theatres. Moview song scenes on TV are unappealing and repetitive these days. I dont know why there has to be a huge crowd of people and stars like suresh gopi and mammootty who have no flair for dancing need to shake through.
Finally foor the song to be heard in public, someone other than me has either to see the movie or hear this cassette and find it interesting. New songs seldom reach me these days.
2. Piracy had been in place everywhere, for last several decades. When gramaphone plate era stopped and vinyl cassettes came into market (1980 onwards i guess) "audio recording centres" popped up like mushrooms and malayalam music industry has faced tougher situation during that time when people almost had no sense of guilt to get songs recorded- copyright laws were not followed those days.
3. Newbies have nothing to offer to appeal me. A looped "Baletta" to the tune of boney M's Rasputin is an insult to me- the loyal music consumer from birth. Revamping pachchappananthathe to the tune of pottithakarnna kinaakkal primarily assumes that me, the listener has no sense or memoires.
"mazhakkalamalle mazhayalle pookkalam alle pookkalalle" is assaulting my poetic sense.
4. There are very good old time and new generation poets and MDs around, but they are not in picture any more or are forced to come up with good for nothing lines and tunes. I would blame that on movie and TV serial directors who have no flair for music or anything for that matter.
I listen to two hours of music at least 6 times a day (while jogging and driving to work) without fail. I would have gladly purchased any good new song available in the market. Unfortunately there is nothing that appeals me. If you ask my opinion on the crisis, its a vendor's failure to meet customer demand, not primarily a question of distrubution leakage or lack of demand.
Conclusion: People in the industry assume consumer will buy whatever they think is fair enough. There is no search for quality in any ingredient of a song.
Since I do not sing and am only a listener, may be I can present a consumer's view on this grave issue.
1. There are three ways for a song to reach me- when I hear it while watching the movie, when I watch song scenes on TV or hearing it at a public place & finding it appealing to me.
Now, there has to be a real appealing movie to get me spending a few hundred rupees and keep shut inside foul air chambers called cinema theatres. Moview song scenes on TV are unappealing and repetitive these days. I dont know why there has to be a huge crowd of people and stars like suresh gopi and mammootty who have no flair for dancing need to shake through.
Finally foor the song to be heard in public, someone other than me has either to see the movie or hear this cassette and find it interesting. New songs seldom reach me these days.
2. Piracy had been in place everywhere, for last several decades. When gramaphone plate era stopped and vinyl cassettes came into market (1980 onwards i guess) "audio recording centres" popped up like mushrooms and malayalam music industry has faced tougher situation during that time when people almost had no sense of guilt to get songs recorded- copyright laws were not followed those days.
3. Newbies have nothing to offer to appeal me. A looped "Baletta" to the tune of boney M's Rasputin is an insult to me- the loyal music consumer from birth. Revamping pachchappananthathe to the tune of pottithakarnna kinaakkal primarily assumes that me, the listener has no sense or memoires.
"mazhakkalamalle mazhayalle pookkalam alle pookkalalle" is assaulting my poetic sense.
4. There are very good old time and new generation poets and MDs around, but they are not in picture any more or are forced to come up with good for nothing lines and tunes. I would blame that on movie and TV serial directors who have no flair for music or anything for that matter.
I listen to two hours of music at least 6 times a day (while jogging and driving to work) without fail. I would have gladly purchased any good new song available in the market. Unfortunately there is nothing that appeals me. If you ask my opinion on the crisis, its a vendor's failure to meet customer demand, not primarily a question of distrubution leakage or lack of demand.
Conclusion: People in the industry assume consumer will buy whatever they think is fair enough. There is no search for quality in any ingredient of a song.
Dear Pradipji,
First of all let me give u a belaaaaaaated congratz for achieving the "Lata Mangeshkar Award for the Best Male voice of India"..!!
Its really great to see a senior professional musician on the IP world,giving a chance for the music lovers to interact with..!
Thanks to Jo for routing me here..!
Broadband and a gud soundcard giving freedom for all amateur's to test out any type of music technologies,its gud to an extend unless they think that its the core.Its true that a lot of amateurs are acting as genuine musicians these days but i don't think a real music lover is going to accept them without showing out their real talents,Channel industry injects the youngsters the new defenition of singers "as Chocolate boys or belly dancing galz".A lot of real musicians absence or their lethergy adapting new technologies making these amateur's creating a hell out here..!
Kiranz..!!
First of all let me give u a belaaaaaaated congratz for achieving the "Lata Mangeshkar Award for the Best Male voice of India"..!!
Its really great to see a senior professional musician on the IP world,giving a chance for the music lovers to interact with..!
Thanks to Jo for routing me here..!
Broadband and a gud soundcard giving freedom for all amateur's to test out any type of music technologies,its gud to an extend unless they think that its the core.Its true that a lot of amateurs are acting as genuine musicians these days but i don't think a real music lover is going to accept them without showing out their real talents,Channel industry injects the youngsters the new defenition of singers "as Chocolate boys or belly dancing galz".A lot of real musicians absence or their lethergy adapting new technologies making these amateur's creating a hell out here..!
Kiranz..!!
- Posted at 3:08 PM | By Kiranz..!!
Came from Jo's. Good to see you start a blog with a very pertinent topic. From what I'm reading it looks like the M. Music industry is at crossroads and I think it is quite normal for it to be in a period of chaos before the dust settles and a trend emerges. You've discussed about two aspects , about the old method of producing and distributing music and the advent of a more techno(logy) orientiented music. I seriously doubt that musicians will be out of job, just because of the emerging technologies. There will be a shift in what they work on, because I believe a musician world isn't restricted to film music alone. I'm not sure about home studios also. Home studios are no match for professional recording studios, people who need to use high end gadgets will invariably seek these. I'm also interested knowing who is creating music in these home studios and how it is distributed.
Music being very subjective, no one will be able to dictate what good music stands for and what one should listen to. I think there is a market for all kinds of music. The best, one could do is create the kind of music you like/believe in and let the market take over.
PS : I don't have any numbers from the Indian Music industry, but in 2005 alone the old dads of Rolling stones made a whopping $162 million.
Music being very subjective, no one will be able to dictate what good music stands for and what one should listen to. I think there is a market for all kinds of music. The best, one could do is create the kind of music you like/believe in and let the market take over.
PS : I don't have any numbers from the Indian Music industry, but in 2005 alone the old dads of Rolling stones made a whopping $162 million.
- Posted at 8:13 PM | By Prem Abraham
Excellent Pradip,
I truly agree with you on the copyright matters. Moreover, I wish that the IT industry brings up new laws and restrictions so that music/movies online are sold the same way audio cassettes/CDs are sold at physical locations. I am sure in about 20 years, there will be something like that coming up. But right now, it's all a bit crazy.
I also agree with you on the talent of the current 'young' musicians. Copying, aping pop star singing and cheap gimmicks seem to be the way to make it to the top. How many young singers have a degree or have studied music for many years and understand the nuances? We all love to sing and put on a Yesudas cassette and try to ape his singing, and after about 300 trials, we can sorta match him. But do we his real talent. Can we sing like him giving anything? It's sad to see genuine talent be overshadowed.
And thanks for enlightening me about this 'sponsoring' business. Truly sad.
-Kajan
I truly agree with you on the copyright matters. Moreover, I wish that the IT industry brings up new laws and restrictions so that music/movies online are sold the same way audio cassettes/CDs are sold at physical locations. I am sure in about 20 years, there will be something like that coming up. But right now, it's all a bit crazy.
I also agree with you on the talent of the current 'young' musicians. Copying, aping pop star singing and cheap gimmicks seem to be the way to make it to the top. How many young singers have a degree or have studied music for many years and understand the nuances? We all love to sing and put on a Yesudas cassette and try to ape his singing, and after about 300 trials, we can sorta match him. But do we his real talent. Can we sing like him giving anything? It's sad to see genuine talent be overshadowed.
And thanks for enlightening me about this 'sponsoring' business. Truly sad.
-Kajan
- Posted at 11:39 PM | By Anonymous